The DWYER is named for the Dwyer brothers, Mike and Phil. The Brooklyn wholesale meat distributors developed one of America's greatest racing stables. Originally the Brooklyn Derby, the name of the race was changed to Dwyer in 1918.
The 1920 renewal of The DWYER developed into a match race between the great Man o' War and John P. Grier when other horses declined to face the issue. The event turned out to be the toughest race in the big chestnut's career. The two raced as one for most of the mile and a furlong distance with John P. Grier getting in front at the eighth pole, only to have Man o' War come on to win by more than a length.
The DWYER was run at old Aqueduct from 1918 to 1955; at Jamaica in 1956 and 1959; at Aqueduct from 1960 to 1974, and in 1976. Run at a mile and five sixteenths in 1925; a mile and a half from 1926 to 1934; a mile and three sixteenths from 1956 to 1959; a mile and a quarter from 1940 to 1955, and from 1960 to 1974; and at a mile and an eighth from 1975 to 1993. Run as the Dwyer Handicap from 1957 to 1978. In 1940, Snow Ridge finished first, but was disqualified. In 1992, Three Peat finished first but was disqualified and placed second.