by David Aragona
Visit TimeformUS to view this card’s Highlight Horse and get PPs.
Race 1: 3 - 2 - 1 - 5
Race 2: 4 - 7 - 1 - 2
Race 3: 7 - 1 - 3 - 4
Race 4: 2 - 8 - 5 - 9
Race 5: 3 - 2 - 9 - 1A
Race 6: 2 - 7 - 4 - 6
Race 7: 3 - 5 - 2 - 7
Race 8: 7 - 2 - 3 - 6
Race 9: 2 - 9 - 10 - 1
(Guide - WIN: recommended win/key horse at fair odds; UPGRADE: value horses I picked underneath to consider upgrading in vertical/horizontal wagers; USE: runners to include in vertical exotic wagers with Win horse)
RACE 1: RIA’S ANGEL (#3)
#2 Colloquy is obviously the horse to beat off his runner-up finish at this level last time, in which he earned a field-best 92 TimeformUS Speed Figure. The slight stretch-out in distance appeared to work for this son of Flatter, who was more engaged early than he had been in his career debut. I thought he hung in the late stages last time after appearing to have dead aim at the winner, but his rider Dylan Davis did drop the whip in upper stretch. Colloquy may be too tough for this field to handle if he takes another step forward, but he’s going to be an awfully short price and there are some others in this field with upside. #1 Curlin’s Wisdom could go off as the second choice after rallying for third going a mile in the slop last time. I thought he ran better than the result might indicate that day, as the race was dominated towards the front end, and he overcame poor early position. He’s caught three wet tracks in a row and may finally get back on a fast surface here. He’s also switching into the Linda Rice barn, though I’m not sure that’s a negative given the recent cold streak for that stable. My top pick is #3 Ria’s Angel. He’s made two of his four starts against maiden claimers, but has run some fast races. He was arguably best in his career debut when he blew the start and made a wide run over a rail-biased surface. He didn’t fare as well in maiden special weight company after that, but he was facing some pretty strong rivals in those spots. Distance is obviously the major question mark, but progeny of Upstart win a strong 18% of their dirt route attempts. It also feels like this horse might have been claimed by Horacio De Paz with the stretch-out in mind. He certainly is a determined finisher, so I’m optimistic that he can handle the step up in trip.
WIN: #3 Ria's Angel, at 3-1 or greater
RACE 2: BAR FOURTEEN (#4)
John Terranova scratched one of his entrants, which means #2 Breadman should go off as the favorite. He looked so promising when he won his career debut over the Belmont turf back in 2020. However, his subsequent grass starts haven’t been particularly strong. He returned from a layoff on dirt this winter and ran decently on Feb. 5 before regressing at a mile last time. He should be fit for this return to turf, but he needs to finally take that next step forward, and I don’t need him at a short price. Florida shipper #7 Uncle Curly makes some sense as an alternative, but he doesn’t possess that much early speed either. It appears that he’s coming out of cheaper races, but he actually faced some decent rivals at Gulfstream and should be able to translate that form to this state-bred allowance. Yet I want the speed, #4 Bar Fourteen. He’s done most of his recent running on the dirt, but he’s been effective on turf in the past. Among his turf efforts are an impressive maiden score last June, in which he earned a 110 TimeformUS Speed Figure, and a prior runner-up finish to the talented Ocala Dream. He’s been a little inconsistent on dirt recently, but he’s clearly capable of producing a winning effort when he has his mind on running. I don’t care about his marathon try last time, as he’s now cutting back to a better distance. It seems like a good sign that these connections are reaching out to Joel Rosario.
WIN: #4 Bar Fourteen, at 5-2 or greater
RACE 3: DONTBELATE (#7)
I’m reluctant to take a short price on #1 Tough Tickets, though I acknowledge he is the horse to beat. A repeat of his return effort in March will probably be good enough to get the job done against this weaker field. However, he’s stretching out for the first time, and dropping again for Todd Pletcher after a claim was voided by the vet. Pletcher is just 4 for 30 ($0.55 ROI) second off a layoff of 180+ days in claiming races over the past 5 years. I’m just not confident enough in him to swallow a price around even-money. #3 Noble Journey is the obvious alternative as he, too, drops down from the $25k N2L level. However, he’s coming off an uncharacteristically poor effort last time. It should be noted that all of his best dirt efforts have come over wet tracks, so I don’t fully trust him to show up on fast going, even against this softer field. If I’m going to search for an alternative to the favorite, I’d rather go for a lightly raced option. #7 Dontbelate obviously has to find some improvement to upset the favorite if that one shows up, but this race gets a lot easier if Tough Tickets regresses. Dontbelate is coming out of a tougher spot last time, as that April 10 claiming affair may have been stronger than the speed figure indicates. We’ve already seen a couple horses return from that race to register higher numbers in their next starts. David Donk is just dropping him down to an appropriate level now, and I think he’s getting a subtle rider upgrade to Luis Cardenas.
WIN: #7 Dontbelate, at 7-1 or greater
RACE 5: SANCTUARY CITY (#3)
If #2 Soldier Rising is ready to fire off the bench, he is clearly the most likely winner. However, he’s still searching for his first victory in the U.S. and this is a pretty salty optional claiming field. This gelding did run well in all of his starts in this country last year. He got great trips in the Saratoga and Jockey Club Derbies but wasn’t as fortunate in the Hill Prince when he got no pace ahead of him and was forced to make a wide run. He closed out his campaign with a career-best effort against older horses in the G2 Red Smith, flying late to just miss. With routine improvement as a 4-year-old, this could be the stepping stone to graded stakes success. However, Christophe Clement is a mediocre 13 for 80 (16%, $1.40 ROI) off 120-240 day layoffs in turf routes at NYRA over the past 5 years. This horse also lacks any early speed and there’s not that much pace signed on in this 10-furlong affair. #3 Sanctuary City finished behind Soldier Rising when they met in the Red Smith last year, but the three-turn, 11-furlong trip of that race was probably too demanding for this James Ferraro trainee. He was also trying to rally inside that day when it seemed like the best running was being down out in the center of the course. This horse rarely takes much money despite the fact that he’s earned a strong set of speed figures over the past year. I like that he got a prep under his belt at Aqueduct so he figures to be fit for this stretch-out to 1 1/4 miles over his favorite track. He probably isn’t as naturally talented as Soldier Rising, but the expected disparity in price between the two makes Sanctuary City more appealing. I considered some others like #1A Box N Score, though his last victory may have been enhanced by yielding ground. #9 Slicked Back can also improve, but he wasn’t quite as good as Soldier Rising last year.
WIN: #3 Sanctuary City, at 7-2 or greater
RACE 8: MISS MAJORETTE (#7)
Christophe Clement holds a strong hand in this License Fee, as he seconds out the first two choices on the morning line, including likely favorite #2 Too Sexy. Clement’s numbers coming off layoffs aren’t particularly strong, so perhaps this mare will need a race. She also sports a pretty sparse worktab for this return and Clement himself has acknowledged that this race may be coming up a little quick for her. She was in stellar form last year, reeling off a couple of 6-furlong victories at Belmont in the fall before just missing as the favorite in the Autumn Days. A repeat of any of those performances will make her tough to beat. However, she has to overcome the layoff as well as a general lack of pace in this race. I do prefer her to Clement’s other runner #3 Miss J McKay. She did win an allowance race on this circuit at Aqueduct last fall, but she got a great trip in doing so. Her last few starts have come going shorter at Gulfstream, and the form from those races is mixed. She did have a significant excuse when getting steadied early two back. Yet she was very dull on synthetic last time and needs to bounce back. Some may be tempted to go for horses who can be forwardly placed, but even the likely speed #4 Igloo just doesn’t do a whole lot for me. I want to go in a different direction for a price. #7 Miss Majorette didn’t run quite as well as Too Sexy in the Autumn Days last year, but she didn’t run that much worse at 37-1. She had been a progressive sort coming into that race, having run well in all of her turf sprints, and she clearly took a step forward stretching out to 6 furlongs. Like the favorite, she’s coming off a layoff, but is doing so for a new barn, having been transferred to Mark Casse. It’s unclear if she can continue her forward movement, but she’s going to be a much bigger price than Too Sexy and has the kind of late kick that might be able to overcome a slow pace.
WIN: #7 Miss Majorette, at 5-1 or greater
RACE 9: STREET FIGHT (#2)
I suppose #10 Devil’s Outlaw will attract plenty of support in this finale as he returns from a layoff and makes his first start for the Chad Brown barn. This will also mark his turf debut, as all of his prior starts came over all-weather going in Ireland. While he did run well in a few of those overseas starts, he appears to be a horse that has quite a bit of hang in him. He got winning trips in a few of those races and just seemed all too willing to let rivals pass him in the lane. He’s bred to be a good one, as a half-brother to Brown’s Grade 1 turf winner Competitionofideas. However, there are some younger rivals with upside in this field, so I don’t want to just default to these connections at a short price. I have similar feelings about #1 Urban Forest, who is among the most experienced members of this field. His turf races have been pretty good, but he’s never run a particularly fast speed figure. I do like the turnback in distance for him, but it’s not as if he was meeting particularly tough fields when he ran well at Aqueduct last fall. There are a couple of runner from lower profile barns that I find more intriguing. One of those is #9 Smoke and Heat, who makes his turf debut for Tony Dutrow. This horse has plenty of pedigree to handle the surface being by Street Boss out of a turf-winning dam who has also produced a turf winner by Tonalist. This horse ran on well in his dirt sprint debut, but was striding out like a horse that should have no problem transferring his form to turf. My top pick is another son of Street Boss. #2 Street Fight made two starts on grass last year, and I thought he ran pretty well each time. He was facing a decent field when he made his turf debut last summer at Saratoga, and he stayed on well after contesting the pace. He subsequently finished third by over 6 lengths in his only other turf start at Monmouth. However, that was an unusually strong field for that venue. Winner Unanimous Consent is now a stakes winner and still undefeated in 3 starts, while runner-up There Are No Words returned to break his maiden by over 10 lengths. This horse is on the smaller side, and will probably appreciate the slight turnback to 7 furlongs. He also goes out for a barn that hasn’t yet started any runners this year, so he figures to fly under the radar.
WIN: #2 Street Fight, at 5-1 or greater
UPGRADE: #9 Smoke and Heat, at 5-1 or greater